Consistency rules compared: the same week at five futures prop firms
A consistency rule compares your largest winning day with your total gain. If one day is too large a share, the payout waits until more, smaller days bring the share down. The five firms below set the line in different places, measure it over different windows, and treat the exact line differently. Some have no such rule at all and count qualifying days instead.
The rules side by side
| Firm and account | Largest day must be | Measured against | On the line, and over it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apex (Performance Account) | below 50% | net gain since the last payout | exactly 50%: the text says below, Apex's own example accepts it |
| Topstep XFA (Consistency path) | at or below 40% | net gain in the payout window | exactly 40% counts; nothing is rounded |
| Topstep Trading Combine | at or below 55% | total gain in the Combine | exactly 55% counts; over it, the amount needed to pass rises |
| Lucid (LucidPro funded) | no more than 40% (35% on older accounts) | net gain in the payout cycle | exactly 40%: the page says both no more than and below |
| TakeProfitTrader (Test) | below 50% | net gain in the Test | exactly 50% does not pass; over it, the goal becomes more than twice the largest day |
| Lucid (LucidFlex funded), Tradeify (Select funded) | none | – | five qualifying days count instead |
The share is always the same arithmetic: the largest single day divided by the net gain over the window, losing days included. A losing day lowers the net gain, so it raises the share. What differs is the line, whether touching the line counts, and what happens when you are over it.
One week, five firms
Take one 50K account and six trading days: a strong first day, four smaller winning days and one small loss. Here is what each firm's published payout rules say about the same days.
| Firm and account | The rule | This week | Payout? | Still missing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apex EOD Performance Account | largest day below 50% of the net gain | 51.72% | not yet | net gain past 3,000.00 |
| Topstep XFA, Consistency path | largest day at or below 40% of the net gain | 51.72% | not yet | net gain at least 3,750.00 |
| Topstep XFA, Standard path | five winning days of 150 or more | 5 days | yes | – |
| LucidPro funded | largest day no more than 40% of the net gain | 51.72% | not yet | net gain at least 3,750.00 |
| LucidFlex funded | five days of 150 or more; no consistency rule | 5 days | yes | – |
| Tradeify Select Flex | five winning days of 150 or more; no consistency rule | 5 days | yes | – |
| TakeProfitTrader Test (to pass) | largest day below 50% of the net gain | 51.72% | not yet | net gain past 3,000.00 |
The first day is 51.72% of the week's net gain, so every firm with a consistency rule says not yet, but the amount they ask for differs: a net gain past 3,000 where the line is 50%, and at least 3,750 where it is 40%. The firms that count qualifying days instead look only at how many days reached their minimum, and those days are in the list already.
What follows from the arithmetic
- After a large day, smaller winning days are what bring the share down. A day larger than the current largest day becomes the new largest day and raises the gain needed.
- A losing day costs twice in a consistency window: it lowers the gain, and so it raises the share of the largest day.
- The window matters. Apex, Topstep and Lucid measure since the last payout, so the count starts again after each one; TakeProfitTrader's rule applies to the Test.
- On the exact line, read the firm's wording. "Below 50%" and "at or below 40%" are different rules at the boundary, and on two of the firms' pages the exact line is stated two ways.
This is arithmetic on published rules, not advice on how to trade. Each firm's dashboard decides a payout.
To run your own days against any of these limits, use the consistency rule calculator: it shows the largest day's share and how much more net gain you need.
Sources
Every rule here comes from the firm's own help center, read by hand on 2026-11-16 with a fingerprint of the exact text, and is checked again every week. The pages and fingerprints are listed on each firm's page: Apex, Topstep consistency rule, TakeProfitTrader, Lucid Trading, Tradeify. Alpha Futures, added later: Alpha Futures consistency rule (40%).